7 “Innovative” Ways Of Repelling Top-Tier Applicants From Your Company’s Business Development Vacancies
There are certain ways of attracting talented business development people and certain ways of repelling them. It seems over the years the HR departments of so many IT companies have become experts at repelling talented folks, but instead of examining their own hiring flaws, they keep hiring mediocre people and keep paying the price of sky-high attrition.
And since HR departments have never been accountable for the calibre of hired people, so they keep hiring the wrong people and the company keeps paying the price for the hiring mistakes.
Let's look at 7 of these repelling factors...
1. “We thank all applicants, but we contact only the ones we’re interested in”
This sends a loud and clear message to applicants: “Folks, we hereby promise to treat you like shit both before and after hiring you.” Technology is widely available to communicate with all candidates, and keeping them in the loop regarding how the recruitment process is going. And eventually you can announce that, “Folks, we have a winner and this message ends our recruitment process for this position. Thanks for your interest and we wish you the best of luck.”
2. “Send your cover letter and resume to hr@abc.com”
Talented people know that HR folks have no functional understanding of the positions their companies advertise, thus they can’t recognise real talent. They can match resumes against rigid job descriptions, and this is good for ordinary workers working on production belts or digging ditches. Top-notch knowledge workers are seeking for some more. First, as opposed to jobs, they’re seeking careers.
3. “We offer a highly competitive salary and bonuses”
Highly competitive salaries are for highly competitive people. That is, also rans. Exceptional people, that is, real talents, while they’re not working for money per se, expect exceptional compensation. Also, truly exceptional people are usually not competitive, except competing with themselves. They have the league of their own, so competition is unnecessary.
4. Not revealing the name of the hiring company
Recently it’s become popular for - mainly low-brow, bottomfeeder - companies to place their career ads without revealing their names. This nameless approach often screams scam, and quality applicants don’t even waste their time to apply. Eventually the company ends up with low quality applicants from the bottom of the unemployment scum barrel.
Just check Craigslist. Most of those companies that call themselves industry leaders turn out to be hopeless losers with so much notoriety that revealing their names would work against them.
5. “We pay excellent commissions”
This is obvious. Many companies don’t want to invest their own money in their growth, so they expect business development folks to work on some kind of commission structure. So, these folks take 100% of the risk and invest 100% of their time, effort, expertise and money to find new business, and then the company takes 90% of the rewards and the hard working folks get a mere 10%.
Again, only the most desperate folks apply for this position. Or the folks who are driven by money, but those are usually not the best but merely the greediest. And that’s fine if the company is hiring peddlers to sell commodities. But companies that sell unique, complex, high-ticket solutions has to think again. Also, it’s usually the seriously troubled companies that are looking for suckers who are willing to give their best and brightest for mere promises of future payment.
6. Offering full-time positions
Knowledge work is not about being full-time but rather being full engagement. It doesn’t matter how many hours I spend in an office staring at a computer screen looking busy, at the end of the day it’s up to me how engaged I am to the work I do. And the result of my work is a function of my engagement level not the function of the number of hours I appear to be busy in an office.
7. “We pay competitive hourly wages”
This is basically about treating knowledge workers as manual labourers: The most important value-creating traits of knowledge workers can’t be measured. They must be must be judged and discerned by people with significant level of expertise in the subject matter. Knowledge work is non-linear, thus can’t be subjected to the cadences and rhythms of an assembly line or a group of people shovelling manure. Knowledge work progresses by iteration and reiteration, a process of the mind.
The traditional productivity metrics of manual labour must be replaced by judgment and discernment. The problem is that judgement requires expertise but measurement only requires a measuring stick. And only experts can judge but any idiot can measure. And sadly, the world is full of idiots who are obsessed with measurement because they are too lazy or dumb to acquire the expertise that would allow them to judge. Hence, a large percentage of knowledge workers work for idiots.
Business development folks must be regarded as knowledge workers. Sadly, this is a mysterious feat 99.99% of HR professionals simply can’t comprehend because they are so hopelessly stuck in the industrial age. Besides, the best candidates know they have no chance to battle it out with HR, so unless they can connect with executives, they don’t even apply.
In a recent post at Execupundit, Michael Wade named seven reasons why candidates avoid the HR department. Later employment attorney, John Phillips elaborated on Michael’s points. Here you can read the whole article, entitled Why Employees Don’t Go to HR.
So, I suggest that if your company is still burdened by an HR department, then dissolve it and enlighten your company with people who understand talents and knowledge workers, so your company can actually attract top talents. People who know how to do things not merely people with impressive resumes.


